Symbolism isn’t enough: What Tennessee’s MLK streets reveal about investment and power

A

Members of Nashville’s City Council, including bill sponsor Sharon Hurt, in white, celebrate the naming of a portion of Nashville’s Charlotte Ave. for Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr., on April 4, 2018. (Photo: Nashville.gov)

Across the country, streets named for Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. don’t need explaining in Black communities. 

They are known by feel. Among long corridors where beauty supply stores sit beside corner stores, where barbershops outlast boarded-up buildings, where potholes crowd the pavement and front-porch conversations stretch past sundown. These are not symbolic roads. They are places where Black life continues, day after day, despite decades of disinvestment, living in the shadow of a name that promised justice long before cities were ready to deliver it.

In Tennessee, King’s legacy is etched into the geography of the state itself. His name appears on green street signs and stretches of asphalt that carry daily life: commuters heading to work, children walking to school, and churches opening their doors on Sunday mornings.

But those streets did not come easily.

The fight to name roads after King in the Volunteer state unfolded over decades, shaped by local politics, racial resistance and a persistent question about where, and how, Black history is allowed to exist in public space: Is naming a street after King an act of honor, or a substitute for the economic and political investment his work demanded?

There are now more than 1,000 streets named for King; globally, including at least 955 in the United States, according to University of Tennessee geographer Derek Alderman, whose extensive research over the last two decades has examined the geography of King streets nationwide. Those streets span 41 states, Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico, many emerging after King’s assassination in 1968 and again following the establishment of the federal holiday in 1983.

A close-up photo of a man with light red hair, goatee and glasses.
More than 1,000 streets across the world are named for Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., says Derek Alderman, Ph.D., professor of geography at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. (Photo: University of Tennessee)

Tennessee has at least 17 streets bearing King’s name, stretching across the state’s largest cities and extending into smaller rural communities, such as Bolivar, New Market and Rockwood, sometimes no more than narrow back roads, absent from Google Maps and quietly maintained by residents determined to ensure King’s name remains visible.

“There’s been a fairly typical pattern across the United States,” Alderman said. “None of this happens without Black activism. Black communities, Black clergy, and those who have pushed very hard to get King’s name on a prominent road, one that doesn’t just serve the Black community, but transcends it.”

What often results, he said, is a compromise shaped by resistance: King’s name confined to a short stretch of roadway, frequently within historically Black neighborhoods, a form of symbolic recognition that mirrors the very segregation King spent his life challenging.

“That’s what makes street naming so controversial,” Alderman said. “It’s not really a question of whether we will remember Dr. King. It’s a question of where we will remember him. Where we choose to remember King plays a major role in shaping the meaning of that commemoration.”

Unfinished symbols and the cost of commemoration

For all their visibility, Martin Luther King, Jr. streets carry a deep contradiction. They are meant to honor a man who preached economic justice and structural change, yet many of the corridors that bear his name remain sites of concentrated poverty and neglect.

That pattern, Alderman said, is not accidental.

“MLK streets are often placed in historically Black neighborhoods that have already experienced redlining, urban renewal and disinvestment,” he said. “So what you get is this uncomfortable reality where we symbolically honor Dr. King, but materially fail to address the inequalities that his work was fundamentally about.”

Research has repeatedly shown that the symbolism of MLK street-naming is rarely matched by economic investment. A 2020 study found that areas surrounding MLK-named streets are, on average, more segregated and significantly poorer than the national norm, with property values that consistently lag behind the rest of their cities. In majority-Black neighborhoods, homes are routinely appraised 20 to 23%lower than comparable properties in white neighborhoods, limiting wealth-building while increasing financial burden. Property values shape everyday life, influencing whether families can build wealth, access credit, fund public schools and pass stability to the next generation.

None of this happens without Black activism. Black communities, Black clergy, and those who have pushed very hard to get King’s name on a prominent road, one that doesn’t just serve the Black community, but transcends it.

– Derek Alderman, Ph.D., University of Tennessee

On Martin Luther King, Jr. Avenue in East Knoxville, longtime business owner Tanika Harper said the street’s name has always carried weight but not protection. Her family, through the generations, has held on to property on the road for decades, and she says it’s intentional.

“I’m proud to be on MLK, ” Harper said, speaking of the commercial building space her father originally operated his long standing lawncare company out for decades. “We’ve always found ways to thrive. I want to see this become a corridor that truly reflects Dr. King’s vision, where people can live, work, heal and build generational wealth. The potential is here. What’s needed now is the will to invest in people, not just property.

Alderman argues that street naming should be understood not as a finish line, but as a starting point, one that forces cities to confront whether they are willing to back symbolism with policy, resources, and sustained investment, particularly at a moment when public commitments to racial equity and diversity initiatives are being openly dismantled.

“The name should come with a commitment,” Alderman said. “Otherwise, it becomes a reminder of what cities are willing to say, and what they’re unwilling to do.”

Nashville: Putting King in the path of power

Nashville’s connection to King predates nearly every other Tennessee city. Long before street signs bore his name, the city served as a proving ground for the modern civil rights movement. In 1960, Black college students launched sit-ins that dismantled segregation at downtown lunch counters, drawing King to the city that spring, where he praised Nashville’s campaign as among the most disciplined in the South.

Yet despite that legacy, Nashville waited nearly six decades to place King’s name on a street tied to political power.

Metro Councilmember and mayoral candidate Sharon Hurt, photographed at a June 2023 forum. (Photo: John Partipilo)
Metro Councilmember and mayoral candidate Sharon Hurt, photographed at a June 2023 forum. (Photo: John Partipilo)

That changed in 2018, when the Metro Council approved renaming a portion of Charlotte Avenue, a major corridor adjacent to the Tennessee State Capitol, as Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Boulevard. The decision came during the 50th anniversary year of King’s assassination, sharpening questions of how, and where, his legacy should be honored.

The legislation was led by then Metro Councilmember Sharon Hurt, a Memphis native who said the idea had stayed with her long before she held public office.

“I had seen Martin Luther King, Jr. Boulevards all over the country,” Hurt said. “And typically, those streets reside in the African American community. Considering the contributions he made and how he brought so many people together, I felt his legacy deserved recognition beyond that.”

Once elected, Hurt said she became intentional not just about whether King should be honored, but where.

“I find it poetic justice that he was assassinated in the state of Tennessee,” she said. “With the Capitol on Charlotte Avenue, even naming a portion of that street mattered. I wanted something that could actually succeed.”

As she researched the corridor’s past, Hurt uncovered deeper layers of meaning. Charlotte Avenue was once Cedar Street, an area tied to Black residency, the slave trade and even the construction of the Capitol itself.

“There was an African American man who fell into a hole during the building of the state capitol and was never recovered,” Hurt said. “He’s actually buried there. All of that history is part of that street.”

The ordinance moved swiftly and was signed on April 4, 2018, the anniversary of King’s death.

“It was probably one of the most significant pieces of legislation that I passed,” Hurt said. “I’m very proud of it.”

Still, she is clear-eyed about what symbolism alone can and cannot do.

“A lot of what cities do around civil rights is performative,” Hurt said. “There’s no real equity if you’re not addressing the economic divide, the lack of investment in Black businesses, and the systems that still disadvantage Black communities.”

Memphis: Still reckoning with the mountaintop

If Nashville’s debate centered on proximity to power, Memphis’s struggle was shaped by its grief.

In 1968, King came to Memphis to stand with striking sanitation workers demanding dignity, fair wages, and recognition of their humanity. On April 3, he delivered his final public address, the “Mountaintop” speech, at Mason Temple. He was assassinated the following day at the Lorraine Motel.

Few cities are as permanently linked to King’s final days as Memphis, a reality that weighed heavily on former City Councilmember Berlin Boyd.

“Being in Memphis, the city where Dr. King was assassinated, I was appalled that there were over 900 cities across the country with streets honoring his legacy, but here, where he lost his life, we didn’t have one,” Boyd said.

The delay was not for lack of effort. As early as the 1970s, Rev. James Netters pushed Memphis leaders to rename a street for King in an attempt that failed.

In 2012, Boyd introduced legislation to rename a downtown stretch of Linden Avenue as Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Avenue. The location was deliberate.

“You’re talking about Clayborn Temple, the sanitation workers’ march toward City Hall, and then his assassination at the Lorraine Motel,” Boyd said. “That’s the significance behind Linden Avenue.”

For Boyd, the decades-long delay reflected Memphis’s complicated relationship with its past.

The Lorraine Motel sign in Memphis, Tenn.
Photograph by John Partipilo/ Tennessee Lookout ©2024

“When something is painful, people tend to brush it under the rug and think it will go away,” he said. “But nobody ever really stopped to say, ‘Let’s honor him here because this is where it happened.’”

Unlike many MLK corridors nationwide, Linden Avenue now sits amid visible investment. Boyd pointed to redevelopment in the downtown core as evidence that the street may finally begin to reflect King’s legacy.

“You see economic growth in the area where we placed our street,” Boyd said. “But just naming a street after Dr. King doesn’t define what he stood for. There’s still a lot of work that needs to be done.”

Chattanooga: From the big nine to the river

Chattanooga became one of Tennessee’s earliest testing grounds for King street-naming, not only because of when it happened, but because of where city leaders initially tried to draw the line.

“It was one of the first cases I ever encountered,” Alderman said. “A colleague sent me newspaper clippings years ago, and what struck me was that this was a city where activists actually pulled this off politically. They started the process before the King holiday was even established. That’s a real testament to Chattanooga’s traditions of protest and moral clarity.”

In the years following King’s assassination, Black ministers and community leaders pushed to rename Ninth Street, a historically Black commercial corridor known as “The Big Nine.” Once a thriving hub of Black-owned businesses, music, and nightlife, the street’s decline mirrored broader patterns of segregation, urban renewal, and disinvestment.

9th Street was where African Americans were. But the rest of Martin Luther King Boulevard runs to the river, right into prime downtown real estate. And they were very vocal about not wanting to name that portion.

– Rev, William Terry Wood

In 1981, the Chattanooga City Commission initially rejected the proposal, signaling a willingness to rename only East Ninth Street, the portion running through the historically Black neighborhood, while leaving West Ninth, which extended into downtown and prime commercial real estate, untouched.

“Typically, streets are easy to name because they’re already in the Black community,” said Rev.  William Terry Ladd, whose church sits merely blocks away. “That’s usually where the compromise happens.”

Organizers refused to accept it.

“9th Street was where African Americans were. But the rest of Martin Luther King Boulevard runs to the river, right into prime downtown real estate. And they were very vocal about not wanting to name that portion,” Ladd said.

Instead, Black clergy mobilized. In April 1981, hundreds of residents marched up and down Ninth Street, taping bumper stickers reading “Martin Luther King” over existing street signs, symbolically renaming the corridor themselves.

“They unofficially, but defiantly, renamed the street,” said Alderman. “They were repeating the tactics of the civil rights movement to make a claim about public space.”

Ladd said he was not surprised Chattanooga moved early.

“You had pastors who weren’t originally from Chattanooga,” he said. “Many of them went to places like Morehouse (College). They were exposed to a broader theology of justice.”

Later that year, the City Commission reversed course, officially renaming all of Ninth Street as Martin Luther King Boulevard.

“Location shapes meaning,” Alderman said. “And Chattanooga understood that early.”

A portion of Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. Blvd. in Knoxville. (Photo: Angela Dennis)

Knoxville: A door-to-door commitment on East Vine

In Knoxville, the fight unfolded a block at a time.

Charles Mathes, a longtime teacher at Austin High School, spent more than two decades advocating for East Vine and McCalla avenues to be renamed for King. But it was in 1988 that the effort took on new urgency.

That year, Charlene Lewis, Anna Dirl, and a small group of community leaders began walking door to door along East Vine Avenue, carrying a petition asking the city to rename the corridor for King. Lewis had been a sixth grader when King was assassinated, too young to fully grasp the moment but old enough to absorb the stories passed down through her family.

“As I heard these stories, it became more important to me to see us not just get along, but actually make a difference,” Lewis later recalled.

“We knew this wasn’t going to happen unless we did something,” said Rev. Harold Middlebrook of a campaign to name a Knoxville street for Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. (Photo: Screengrab, Knoxville.tn.gov.)

The effort was deeply grassroots, rooted in churches and neighborhood networks, and grounded in a shared understanding of Vine Avenue’s role as the heart of Black Knoxville before urban renewal hollowed it out.

Rev. Harold Middlebrook, a civil rights leader with personal ties to King through Morehouse College, helped lead what he called a commitment to “walking the walk.”

“We had to do more than sit around talking about it,” Middlebrook said. “We knew this wasn’t going to happen unless we did something.”

Not everyone welcomed the change. Lewis recalled at least one business owner using a racist slur in opposition to King’s name. Still, organizers pressed forward, delivering a petition with hundreds of signatures to city officials in January 1989.

That spring, Knoxville unanimously approved the request, creating a three-mile stretch of Martin Luther King Jr. Avenue through East Knoxville.

For Middlebrook, the street would come to represent both progress and unfinished work.

“We had no idea at that time this would become part of history,” he said. “But we knew it mattered.”

SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE



posteditor
posteditor
Articles: 27298